Dram Oil's $187m Negligence Suit Against Deloitte Heads Back to Accra High Court in December
A high-stakes legal battle between Ghanaian petroleum trading company Dram Oil and Trading Limited and one of the world's largest auditing firms, Deloitte and Touche, is set to continue at the Commercial Division of the High Court in Accra this December. At the heart of the case is a claim of over US$187 million in alleged lost profits, making it one of the most significant professional negligence suits currently before Ghana's commercial courts.
What sparked the lawsuit?
The dispute traces its roots to a petroleum transaction involving Dram Oil, Vihama Energy Limited, and CalBank, which provided financing for the deal. Following a 2015 court judgment, the High Court ordered an audit of Vihama's financial records to determine what payments and other funds were owed under the parties' agreement. Deloitte was subsequently appointed by the court to carry out that audit.
Dram Oil's grievance centres on the final audit report Deloitte submitted. According to the company, earlier draft versions of the report showed a financial balance in Dram Oil's favour. However, the final report that was filed with the court reversed that position entirely, concluding instead that Dram Oil owed money to Vihama. Crucially, Dram Oil alleges it was given no opportunity to respond to the reversal before the report was submitted — and that the court subsequently adopted Deloitte's findings.
The company filed its negligence action in May 2022, seeking damages on the grounds that Deloitte breached its duty of care in preparing the audit report. Beyond the US$187.596 million lost profits claim, Dram Oil is also pursuing additional financial claims, interest, and a formal legal declaration that the auditing firm acted negligently.
Deloitte pushes back — and so does Vihama
Deloitte has firmly rejected the allegations, with its legal team, led by counsel Mr Ace Anan Ankomah, maintaining that the firm carried out the audit strictly in accordance with the court's directions, duly submitted its report, and was cross-examined on its findings. The firm has also disputed that it owed Dram Oil any duty of care in the first place — a central legal question the trial will need to resolve.
Deloitte's lawyers have further challenged portions of the witness statement submitted by Dram Oil's first witness, arguing that some of the content goes beyond the company's original pleadings. Dram Oil has opposed those objections.
Vihama Energy, which was joined as a party to the negligence suit, separately applied to have the action against it struck out, arguing that the relevant issues had already been settled in earlier proceedings. Deloitte supported that application, but the High Court dismissed it, ruling that the contested matters were too intertwined with factual questions to be resolved without a full trial. The substantive negligence case therefore continues.
Why it matters for Ghana
This case raises important questions about the accountability of professional service firms operating in Ghana's legal and financial landscape. When courts appoint auditors to assist in resolving commercial disputes, there is an implicit expectation that those auditors will act with care, consistency and transparency. If Dram Oil's version of events — that draft findings were reversed without notice — is ultimately upheld, it could prompt courts and regulators to revisit how court-appointed audit processes are managed and monitored.
For Ghana's growing business community, the outcome could also influence how companies engage with court-ordered financial investigations and what recourse they have when they believe the process has been conducted unfairly. A judgment of this scale, whichever way it goes, is likely to set a significant precedent in Ghanaian commercial law.
- Dram Oil is claiming over US$187 million in lost profits from Deloitte.
- The case stems from a court-ordered audit of a petroleum deal involving CalBank.
- The High Court has already rejected attempts to have the suit struck out before trial.
Source: MyJoyOnline




Comments (0)
Be the first to comment.