General News

Wontumi-EXIM Bank Case: Defence Counsel Atta Akyea Argues Criminal Charges Are a Civil Debt Dispute in Disguise

By · · 3 min read · 20 views
Wontumi-EXIM Bank Case: Defence Counsel Atta Akyea Argues Criminal Charges Are a Civil Debt Dispute in Disguise

Veteran lawyer and former Member of Parliament Samuel Atta Akyea has waded into the high-profile case involving Ashanti Regional NPP Chairman Bernard Antwi Boasiako, widely known as Chairman Wontumi, and the Export-Import Bank of Ghana (EXIM Bank), arguing firmly that what is being prosecuted as a criminal matter is, at its core, a straightforward civil debt dispute.

What the defence is arguing

Atta Akyea, speaking as part of Wontumi's legal defence team, made clear that the team's position is that the substance of the charges against their client does not meet the threshold that warrants a full criminal trial. According to him, the matter revolves around an outstanding debt — the kind of financial obligation that is routinely resolved through civil proceedings, negotiated settlements, or structured repayment arrangements rather than through the criminal justice system.

He stressed that if the debt at the heart of the dispute were to be settled, there would be little justification for the case to continue along criminal lines. The defence appears to be signalling a willingness to engage on the financial aspects of the matter, while simultaneously challenging the appropriateness of the criminal route taken by prosecutors.

Why it matters for Ghana

The Wontumi-EXIM Bank case has drawn significant public attention, not least because of the prominent political profile of the accused. Chairman Wontumi has been one of the most visible figures within the New Patriotic Party, making any legal proceedings involving him inherently political in the eyes of many observers.

Beyond the politics, however, the case touches on a broader and deeply important question about Ghana's legal and financial landscape: when does a failure to repay a commercial loan cross the line from a civil liability into criminal conduct? This is a question that affects businesses, banks, and borrowers across the country.

EXIM Bank, which is a state-backed institution established to support Ghanaian exporters and businesses, has a mandate that makes the recovery of its funds a matter of public interest. Any loans extended by the bank are ultimately backed by public resources, which is why allegations of default or financial misconduct involving its clients attract scrutiny.

At the same time, legal experts have long debated the criminalisation of debt in Ghana, with some arguing that the courts are sometimes used as a pressure tool in commercial disputes rather than as a last resort. Atta Akyea's argument appears to tap into that concern, suggesting the prosecution may be overreaching.

What happens next

The case is expected to continue in the courts, and the defence's position will likely be tested before a judge who will ultimately determine whether the criminal charges can be sustained. If the defence succeeds in framing this as a civil matter, it could lead to either a discontinuation of the criminal proceedings or a parallel push for an out-of-court financial resolution.

Legal observers will be watching closely, as the outcome could set a precedent for how similar disputes between financial institutions and borrowers — particularly high-profile ones — are handled in Ghana going forward. For now, Atta Akyea's public comments suggest the defence is not only preparing its legal arguments for the courtroom but also making its case in the court of public opinion.

Source: 3News

Read next · General News Chairman Wontumi's GH¢30m EXIM Bank fraud case advances to trial after plea talks collapse

Comments (0)

Be the first to comment.

Leave a comment

Get GH Today in your inbox

The day's top Ghana stories — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.